Suspended SA Revenue Service (Sars) commissioner Tom Moyane attacked the judge heading a commission of inquiry into the tax agency during his reign as irrational and biased, saying murderers and serial rapists would get better treatment.
Moyane has described himself as the best Sars commissioner in the democratic era and has rejected accusations that his mismanagement at the tax agency was partly responsible for revenue shortfalls that contributed to the country being hit with a VAT increase this year. He told President Cyril Ramaphosa that retired judge Robert Nugent was irrational and unfair in his recommendation that he be fired immediately.
Tom Moyane’s attorney Eric Mabuza has given Cyril Ramaphosa until next Friday to indicate that he has rejected the commission’s recommendations or risk being taken to court.
The allegations are made in Moyane’s submissions to President Cyril Ramaphosa in which he argues that the president should reject the recommendation that he be fired.
In an interim report filed at the end of last month, retired Judge Robert Nugent found that Moyane does not have the character of a person fit to lead Sars and he should be removed from office as a matter of urgency.
Moyane’s attorney Eric Mabuza drafted the submissions in which he claims his client was never given an opportunity to confront his accusers.
However, the correspondence reveals Judge Nugent gave Moyane numerous opportunities to make submissions before submitting his interim report but he chose not to.
Mabuza adds that Nugent’s report is based on consistent and deliberate distortion of facts but he doesn’t identify these alleged distortions nor does he provide any counter evidence to rebut the findings made against his client.
The attorney has given Ramaphosa until next Friday to indicate that he has rejected the commission’s recommendations or risk being taken to court,
Moyane has also described retired Nugent’s interim report is a “thinly-veiled attempt to campaign for the permanent appointment of Mark Kingon” who is currently acting commissioner.
Mabuza who drafted the submissions for Moyane resorted to biblical references to illustrate the alleged plot against his client.
He says Judge Nugent is hell-bent on portraying Kingon as an angel juxtaposed with the portrayal of Moyane as the devil incarnate.
Mabuza says totally unfounded accusations and insults are made against Moyane but he does address them or provide evidence to rebut Nugent’s findings.